Note: This is a static archive of the site as of May 2016. The dynamic version of the site is no longer available.

I've heard that URLs with ? in them don't get into the search engines. Is this true?

Yes and no.

   Secret Net Tools
Are You Listed?
License Pl8 Genr8tor

   Getting Started
Getting Started:
Welcome (Home Page)
Site Help
Site FAQ
Site Map
List of Sites
Create New Account

Tutorials: (read in this order)
Preparing your Pages for the Search Engines
Using Tooter to submit your site
Getting listed in Yahoo (and the other big indexes)
Paying for Traffic
How to (not) win Awards

Trends in Submission
Virtual Vexation
The 500 Sites Fallacy
Page 1 Paranoia
Clickthrough Conundrums
The Gullibility Virus
A Marketing Course that Works?!
Accepting Credit Cards Online
Links of Interest
Glossary of Useful Terms
Random Nonsense
Woodhead's Law
Cool Domain Names
Why I let you decide how much to pay

Moral obligations?
Be Supportive!
Suggestion Box

About the Site:
How it works
Promotion Monitor
Our Awards
Best User Sites
User Comments

Believe it or not, 11.13% of the people who use support the site!
Some search engines will add urls with ? in them, but many won't. The reason is that typically, a URL with a ? in it indicates that the page contains dynamic content, and the search engines are afraid they'll get trapped in infinite loops when they try and spider the pages.

So in general, URLs with ? in them are a very bad idea.

Many sites use such URLs to support shopping carts; heck, I use the technique when you log into your account on (the ?CODE= stuff identifies who you are). But I'm careful not to start adding that extra stuff to the url until you actually log in. Since a search engine never logs in, it'll never see a ?.

One major sin is sites that automatically create a shopping cart for each visitor. Many search engines see that kind of thing and run away screaming. There's no need to create a shopping cart until a visitor actually adds the first item.

Another even more awful "stupid net trick" is the "redirect to the same page and set a cookie" trick, which a lot of sites running under ASP tend to do. Since search engines ignore cookies, they can get trapped and give up.

See also:

About this site...
This site was developed on a Macintosh, programmed in WebSiphon, and served by WebStar. The author, on those exceedingly rare occasions when he does think, indeed thinks differently. ©1997-2016 Robert Woodhead, All Rights Reserved.™, Tooter™, Secret Net Tools™, MultiSubmitter™, BaldSpotCam™, and ShareService™ are trademarks of Robert Woodhead. To get help, report bugs, or make suggestions, go here.